Bell Hooks, All About Love

Everyone on the planet should force themselves to read (if not
the whole thing, at the very least) chapter one of Bell Hooks’
book, All About Love: New Visions.

When I was a fourteen I went round and round with my first girlfriend
about what “love” meant (like you do) and could we–should we!– say “I
love you.”  We took the common(…?) route of coming up with a code
word that took the pressure off. It was “green pigs”. I believe we were
riffing off the old adage, “Never trust a man selling blue bananas.”

Silly, young esoterica aside, that was the first of many love
conversations with various people which basically went nowhere. Mostly, I
was too young at the time of that first one, but moving on into my 20′s
things never got better. Until I read this:

EXCERPT (in which All About Love quotes The Road Less Traveled)

I was in my mid-twenties when I first learned to
understand love “as the will to extend one’s self for the purpose of
nurturing one’s own or another’s spiritual growth”

RELATED EXCERPT

Had I been given a clear definition of love earlier in my
life it would not have taken me so long to become a more loving person.
Had I shared with others a common understanding of what it means to
love it would have been easier to create love. It is particularly
distressing that so many recent books on love continue to insist that
definitions of love are unnecessary and meaningless.

WITH A BIT THAT’S GOOD FOR A GENDER BLOG

Or worse the authors suggest love should mean something
different to men than it does to women- that the sexes should respect
and adapt to our inability to communicate since we do not
share the same language. This type of literature is popular because it
does not demand a change in fixed ways of thinking about gender roles,
culture or love. Rather than sharing strategies that would help us
become more loving it actually encourages everyone to adapt to
circumstances where love is lacking.

I’d had too many fruitless conversations and resigned myself to
exactly what Hooks says is so common: Not defining or agreeing on the
meaning of love because it seems you can’t. All About Love (which, again, takes it’s definition from The Road Less Traveled) gave me something to actually work with conceptually.

CLOSING EXCERPT with another quote-inside-a-quote from The Road
Less Traveled, which I have had on my shelf for a decade now, but I have
no plans to read it any time soon, despite numerous recommendations. I
am, instead, re-reading All About Love and wondering about the rest of what Bell Hooks has written…

“Love is as love does. Love is an act of will- namely
both an intention and an action. Will also implies choice. We do not
have to love.” Since the choice must be made to nurture growth, this
definition counters the more widely accepted assumption that we
love instinctually.

And really, re-reading this is actually an interlude in a young adult
fantasy/sci-fi binge which started with me suddenly deciding to read
all the Harry Potter books and see all the movies before the last one
came out.

Harry Potter got me thinking about love. It’s a process. I’m just along for the ride.

So, while I insist that you read this, I will also always respect that you haven’t gotten to it yet.

Some are born deviant…

…some achieve deviancy…others have deviancy thrust upon them.

I have always felt myself to be a fairly “vanilla” sort of person.
Because most of my preferences lie only slightly sideways from what was
presented as “normal” on television when I was growing up.

And yet… I have a lot of experience with people believing the contrary about me. Because I’m obviously mostly normal, I wonder if we all have crap like this happen to us.

My freshman year of college, I lived in a large dorm room with two
other people. One of them, Jason (I am not using real names), was a
greater-Minnesota sort-of stoic baseball player. The other, Greg, was a
sporty party guy from the Chicagoland area. Greg would smoke weed in our
room and blow it (kind of) out the window through a two-liter with
dryer sheets in the bottom. Fairly often he would come back to the dorm
smelling like sweaty bread from some combination of drinking and
physical activity. Arguments he would have with his long-distance
girlfriend, “Annie”, would go like this:

Annie.

Annie.

Annie!

Annie.

Why are you being such a bitch?

Annie.

Annie.

Annie.

On a few sweaty, bready nights I was startled awake when Greg shot up
in his bed, shout-mumbled something and then dropped cleanly back into
his inebriated slumber. The only exclamation I ever thought I understood
clearly through his clenched teeth, was:

“Stop Masturbating!”

Time passed. I faked comfort around them. Our room smelled awful. And
toward the end of our first Semester, a classmate of mine, asked me,
“Dude, do you know that your roommate, Greg, is telling everyone on
campus that you are a compulsive masturbater? He says you do it at
night, when they’re both in the room, and they can’t get you to stop.”

I’m sure we talked a bit more, but, in my memory, I shouted,
“WHAT?!”, and five seconds later I was standing in our room, ready
to have it out, staring at Greg’s bed, which had been stripped of
sheets. The rest of his stuff was gone, too.

“Where’s Greg?”

From the other half of our room, unseen, I heard Jason reply, simply, “He dropped out.”

“Oh”, I said, suddenly diffused.

I’d had no warning. My classmate probably told me that night because
he knew Greg was leaving. Turning around, I saw Greg’s parting gift.
Standing prominently on my dresser was an enormous, new, green squeeze
bottle of Johnson & Johnson’s moisturizing lotion with Aloe Vera.

This was a surreal turn of events, but I could kind of picture why he
might have decided to spread a socially-debilitating rumor.

I am so dense sometimes. It hurts to remember these things… but it helps when I make it public, so…

Earlier that year, I got into a fight with my very own long-distance
girlfriend the day before Greg’s was going to visit, and I was scheduled
to hash it out over the phone with mine at a time when I
was absolutely not supposed to be in the dorm room. Greg had
said to Jason and I, with admirable directness, “Annie is coming to
visit. You need to be somewhere else from 5 to 7 p.m. next Wednesday.”

My life was clearly going to end, if my girlfriend and I didn’t solve
this thing that I can’t remember now… not even a little… and I forgot
Greg’s dictate. I walked into the dorm room
and interrupted them. But they were still in their clothes so,
in my tunnel vision on the way to the phone, I only thought. “Annie’s
here. They are napping.”

I waited in the room, out of sight, journaling about relationships, trying to let them sleep, and the call didn’t come.

After a while, Greg came around the divide in our room and growled at
me, “Don’t you have somewhere else to be?!” I finally realized what I
had just done to him, and all I pathetically squeaked out was “I’m
waiting for a phone call…”

“It’s a cordless phone. Go into the hallway.

“Yes. Right.”

I took my cordless across the hall to the kitchen and waited. My
girlfriend didn’t call, and ten minutes later they told me to just come
back in. The damage was done.

That was the worst. I really did that. I tried to apologize but I
probably went and did some other stuff I didn’t know was weird or rude
on top of it. Thus, this masturbation rumor, though not a perfect fit,
was clearly Greg’s vengeance.

Fortunately (or not), this wasn’t the first time in my life that,
I’ve had someone tell an entire group of peers something awful and
untrue behind my back. These are some of the few times in my life where
being spacey and spastic has been a complete boon. You see, like I
said earlier, I am so normal, I keep forgetting to feel
like a pariah. And then I get excited about things and start talking…
Eventually people seem to forget or decide not to care.

I credit myself– I mean it is funny how I forget big awful things
like this mere days after they happen and wonder why people are looking
at me strange– but these situations probably would not have been
forgettable, if I wasn’t lucky enough to have had good friends who
treated me like I was fine and gave me no reason to remember otherwise.

“Oh.”, was the end of the discussion with Jason the day Greg left.
And also with the person who had told me about the gossip. I never
thought to bring it up to him again.

Then, two weeks later, as Jason and I sat quietly on opposite sides
of our room doing homework, Jason suddenly looked up and, with effort,
said to me “Dude, you’ve gotta stop masturbating.”

To which I exlaimed, “What is this?! Why do you think this?!”

Apparently, it wasn’t a complete fabrication. There were suspicious
sounds coming from the direction of my bed every single night.

I promised him emphatically that:

a. I don’t do it. (Which was a lie. I did. Who doesn’t? It’s great. But I was 18 and no one told me it was okay until I was 20.)

b. I would certainly do it more quietly, if I did.

c. If I couldn’t do it quietly, and I really had to, I would
absolutely find a private place, like the bathroom, to try and
accomplish my filthy deed.

Jason still didn’t seem convinced after I was like, ”Look. Me.
In. The. Eye. I am more respectful than that. I promise you. I would
tell you if I had a compulsive masturbation issue.” But there was
nothing more to say.

He told me he still heard sounds and got up once to inspect, but couldn’t hear anything once he approached my bed.

Was it a radiator? People from the floor below us? Our campus had
been written up in Haunted Heartland. It could have been ghosts. Jason,
in his masculinity, couldn’t really describe the sound to me. I
concluded that, if it was me, I was talking in my sleep a little.

And, second semester, Jason moved out. I and my girlfriend (who never
noticed any sounds when she visited) had a four person dorm room all to
ourselves. I was in heaven and told everyone about it.

Do you know why? BECAUSE I REALLY WAS MASTURBATING EVERY SINGLE
NIGHT!!! IT WAS AN IMMENSE PLAN TO GAIN A LARGE ROOM! AND IT
WORKED!!!

Not really.

I assumed we were square and that Jason had out moved for the fun of
living with a friend. Years later, when I figured this whole thing
out and told Jason about it, I could tell that he had never really
believed me, so my happiness must have seemed weird to everyone else. I
wonder now if he ended up telling the person in charge of room
assignments exactly why he wanted to move. I wonder if he told the RA
and tried to get outside help, which is how he managed confront me
instead of also just disappearing.

I still haven’t processed this fully. I’m too spacey, too dense and too freaking normal.

Anyway. I recovered. It actually didn’t affect my social life in any
way that I noticed or cared about. I even made friends with some people
who, after a time, admitted they actively sought me out because they had
to know what an unstoppable masturbater was like.

Apparently everyone I knew in college was a heavy sleeper. After
three years of sleeping near friends, girlfriends and strangers, with no
further comment from anyone, I spent a few weeks sleeping two feet away
from a friend of mine and I eventually woke him up.

I was grinding my teeth.

Loudly.

I was also breathing sharply in with my jaw clenched.

It sounded a lot like maturbation.

Wow.

Now I wear I mouth guard.

My Olive Identity

I like the word queer.

It reminds me of Alice in Wonderland.

Although, that reminds me more of the word “curious”.

I wish I could say I was curious, as in, a curiosity. That’s even
more neat and Victorian. But, alas, that word is inextricably associated
with college experimentation and being burned by partners who were too
afraid or too not gay.

So, queer.

I like saying “I’m queer”, because it’s a pleasant way to say, “I’m human.”

I’ve always connected well with this metaphor: our personality is the
same as frames on a roll of film. When the frames whip by, there
appears to be something moving on the movie screen (I just realized that
shortening “motion picture” to “movie” is like shortening “desk lamp”
to “desky”). And when you make a series of choices you appear to have a
personality or an identity. So… at any time you could just start making
different choices and be a different person.

I mean, easier said than done, of course. We have habits and
preferences. And I see no reason not to go along for the ride.  But
you could just choose to do different things… and then people wouldn’t know you any longer….

Anyway, I hate being told what to do by anyone but me. Especially
when it’s regarding crap which does not matter, like: Men Don’t Knit.

Identifying as queer emphasizes that there is no perfectly identical
overlap between two humans. There is no A or B (not even with your real
physical private bits) but a spectrum between two extremes. And that
spectrum often turns out to not be a line but a circle. And some things
can jump around this circle so it’s more like a ball of yarn and then
your metaphor breaks down… and people don’t know you any longer…

When you go too far in one direction the opposite starts becoming more true.

More True.

Once when I was taking the side of same-sex parenting the person I
was talking with got super-pissed and vehemently accused me of having an
“anything goes” attitude. They were wrong. I like “whatever works.”

We billions are all so freaking queer, it’s a slippery slope trying
to tell people how to behave. Fortunately, we have hearts (in our
brains), and it’s possible, if you cultivate it, to feel things out
moment to moment.

That’s what I’ve found works for me. I didn’t used to like olives and
now I can’t get enough of them. How sad I would be if
I weren’t able to let go of my non-olive identity and embrace
the new change in my bodacious existence (body).

But, good GOD, I can’t handle black olives in the can. Bleaghck. A travesty.